Under $25

A toy designed to get tails waggin'! All Ruff-Tex® toys are constructed with thick-walled latex and have excellent tear-resistance and tensile stre...

A toy designed to get tails waggin'! All Ruff-Tex® toys are constructed with thick-walled latex and have excellent tear-resistance and tensile stre...

This 2-in-1 toy features a soft, plush chick and a durable, non-toxic latex eggshell base. The combination of cuddly and chewy textures makes it pe...

Lulubelles Power Plush toys are constructed using POWER PLUSH! Soft on the outside but tough on the inside! Each whimsical POWER PLUSH toy is backe...

Lulubelles Power Plush toys are constructed using POWER PLUSH! Soft on the outside but tough on the inside! Each whimsical POWER PLUSH toy is backe...

Bow ties have a soft Velcro attachment which allows you to quickly and easily fasten to any collar. Great for everyday wear or celebrating any occa...

Bow ties have a soft Velcro attachment which allows you to quickly and easily fasten to any collar. Great for everyday wear or celebrating any occa...

Get ready to cater to your feline's desire for fun with our Caterpillar Cat Toy! This quirky toy features a cat-friendly caterpillar design, perfec...

Huxley & Kent Kitty Kickers offer Multi-Sensory Play with soft plush on one side & durable burlap for scratching on the other! Oodles of o...

Cheers to Huxley & Kent soft and cozy cat toys! Ultra-soft plush exterior makes this cat toy extra cuddly. They're filled with catnip for enga...

Whiskers and whiskey! Huxley & Kent soft and cozy cat toys! Ultra-soft plush exterior makes this cat toy extra cuddly. They're filled with cat...

Whiskers and whiskey! Huxley & Kent soft and cozy cat toys! Ultra-soft plush exterior makes this cat toy extra cuddly. They're filled with cat...

It's Taco Time with Huxley & Kent soft and cozy cat toys! Ultra-soft plush exterior makes this cat toy extra cuddly. They're filled with catni...

Unleash your cat’s inner hunter with Huxley & Kent Flingers—the ultimate interactive toy that brings excitement and enrichment to playtime! U...

Unleash your cat’s inner hunter with Huxley & Kent Flingers—the ultimate interactive toy that brings excitement and enrichment to playtime! U...

Unleash your cat’s inner hunter with Huxley & Kent Flingers—the ultimate interactive toy that brings excitement and enrichment to playtime! U...

Unleash your cat’s inner hunter with Huxley & Kent Flingers—the ultimate interactive toy that brings excitement and enrichment to playtime! U...

Unleash your cat’s inner hunter with Huxley & Kent Flingers—the ultimate interactive toy that brings excitement and enrichment to playtime! U...

Huxley & Kent soft and cozy cat toys are ultra-soft plush exterior makes this cat toy extra cuddly. They're filled with catnip for engaging pla...

Each whimsical PowerPlush toy is backed inside with an extra layer of durable mesh fused on the inside to make these high-quality, baby soft plush ...

Each whimsical PowerPlush toy is backed inside with an extra layer of durable mesh fused on the inside to make these high-quality, baby soft plush...

A Pizza plush pounce cat toy packed with organic Catnip and crinkle! Kittybelles are wonderful, realistic-looking toys that cats love to bat around...

Power Plush toys are the soft and squeaky distractions that will soon become your pet’s favorite pastime. Each whimsical POWER PLUSH toy is backed...

Power Plush toys are the soft and squeaky distractions that will soon become your pet’s favorite pastime. Each whimsical POWER PLUSH toy is backed...