Under $25

Say hello to Dottie, the coolest puffin’ fluff in town! With her fetching fins and tossable tail, she’ll swim right into your pup’s heart and infl...

Your dog will warm up to Esmeralda quickly. No hard exteriors here - Esmeralda’s shell is soft, plush and ready for snuggling. When she’s not a ...

Georgia Gator is the most popular gal in the swamp, thanks to a shape that any dog can enjoy. From shaking to squeaking to tug-of-war, Georgia’s t...

His long stinger may say “don’t stand so close to me,” but Gordon Stingray is as chill as a day at the beach. His flat body makes the perfect pill...

Our most popular of all the Fluff & Tuff toy family, and possibly the most popular plush toy in our store. Hendrix Fox is a high quality, durab...

Howie is ready to waddle his way into your dog’s heart. His bright yellow feathers and floppy shape make him a great best friend for smaller pooch...

Ready to rule the roost at playtime?Chandler’s the right fowl for the friendship. With his roly-poly body and his floppy legs, there’s no telling w...

Who needs a butterfly when a caterpillar is this adorable? Katie’s a spicebush swallowtail caterpillar who fools predators into thinking she’s a sn...

There’s nothing stinky about Lucy Skunk - in fact, she’s a beautiful little lady with an adorable pink nose and long fluffy tail. She’s soft enough...

  He may look like a crustacean, but Manny's a lover, not a pincher. Your dog will love carrying Manny around by his long tail, and he's a great po...

Your dog will be over the moon about Marge! Her cute coat and feathery tail are sure to make playtime even more fun. Marge is good for shaking, ...

Millie is here to re-generate all sorts of adventures for playtime. Whether it’s tail-tossing, gill-shaking, or fetch-a-fin, your pup is sure to h...

Nuts Squirrel may hoard his acorns, but he’s always ready to share the fun. His fluffy tail is tempting for chasing, but his sturdy body is grea...

Clever, creative play is the name of the game with Olympia Octopus. Her unique shape and eight legs open doors to all kinds of solo and group acti...

Peanut will burrow his way into your dog’s heart! He packs a lot of fun into a tiny package, and particularly loves rousing games of fetch, tug...

When Pigs Fly? Absolutely! Petey loves to soar during a game of fetch with your dog. Even if your pup takes him for a romp in the mud, Petey will ...

Rocket is a lovable rascal who’s always looking for play - and maybe a little bit of mischief. He’s sturdy enough for fetch and tug, but snuggly en...

Savannah is the cutest little gator in the swamp, and she’s ready to play! The smallest of our gator family, Savannah is shaped for tugging, shak...

Whether it’s tail-tugging thrills or snuggling up to chill, Sterling is one sly guy when it comes to finding out how to have fun. He’s ready to pou...

There’s nothing hard about Shelly Turtle - she’s a sweetheart who is perfect for smaller dogs who love a good snuggle. Her floppy legs are separate...

Tank proves that tough things can come in small packages. Whether your smaller dog likes to shake, fetch, tug or play with a group, Tank can tak...

Wally the Flying Mallard will make your dog’s imagination soar with his bright colors and detailed feathery wings. Dogs love to fetch, shake and tu...

Who doesn't want a Hippo for Christmas? Helga Hippo is hungry - for playtime and love all year long. Hippos are surprisingly fast creatures, so ...

Bring out the inner hunter in your pup with Ike the Flying Pheasant. He’s perfect for chasing or shaking by his floppy wings and tail feathers. Ik...