Under $25

Gliding gracefully through the sea, Bleu Narwhal brings an air of mystery to playtime. His tusk stands out from all other toys, and he’s th...

A clever little porpoise with a purpose, Danny Dolphin is always ready to dive in and play. His soft fins, tail, and long nose make him the...

  Gil is one of the most popular fish in the pond, mainly because he loves all types of play. His bold color, separately sewn on fins and tw...

A group of flamingos is called a flamboyance, and Lola lives up to just that. She’s a pretty pink lady with stunning plush feathers. Her long le...

Ruby Rainbow Trout’s streamlined shape will lure your dog right in. Whether you play tug of war or fetch with her, she’ll land your dog hook, ...

Shaggy is one of the friendliest Fluffs you'll ever meet. He likes taking long snuggly naps in the sun. Don't be fooled by his laid-back na...

When it comes to aquatic fun, Squirt and his eight legs will lead the way. He’s a goofy guy who loves solo and group play, including a go...

Baby Bruce Shark is ready to take down playtime. He’s small, but not easily intimidated. While he’s prepared for any sneak attack from dogs of al...

Don’t let his smaller size fool you - Burt is quite the catch for smaller dogs. His long, streamlined shape lures pups in for games of catch or ...

If your pup's got a tiny holiday sweet tooth, this Candy Cane can satisfy! The traditional hook shape is perfect for all types of play and the fest...

Our holiday candy cane is all of the sweet with none of the cavities. Your dog will appreciate the festive plush and a shape that's perfect for tug...

With his bright red plush and frisky fins, Cedar Salmon is quite a catch. But beware, he’s a real player. No dog can resist his charming games of ...

Your dog will warm up to Esmeralda quickly. No hard exteriors here - Esmeralda’s shell is soft, plush and ready for snuggling. When she’s not a ...

Georgia Gator is the most popular gal in the swamp, thanks to a shape that any dog can enjoy. From shaking to squeaking to tug-of-war, Georgia’s t...

His long stinger may say “don’t stand so close to me,” but Gordon Stingray is as chill as a day at the beach. His flat body makes the perfect pill...

Our most popular of all the Fluff & Tuff toy family, and possibly the most popular plush toy in our store. Hendrix Fox is a high quality, durab...

Who needs a butterfly when a caterpillar is this adorable? Katie’s a spicebush swallowtail caterpillar who fools predators into thinking she’s a sn...

  Blue lobsters? They DO exist! And that’s what makes Lucky Lobster so unique. Her flappy tail and snappy claws bring out her colorful personality ...

There’s nothing stinky about Lucy Skunk - in fact, she’s a beautiful little lady with an adorable pink nose and long fluffy tail. She’s soft enough...

He’s big, he’s slick, he’s got tons of teeth - errr, plush … and he really loves being the center of attention. Mac is great for games of tug an...

He may look like a crust crustacean, but Manny's a lover, not a pincher. Your dog will love carrying Manny around by his long tail, and he's a gre...

Nuts Squirrel may hoard his acorns, but he’s always ready to share the fun. His fluffy tail is tempting for chasing, but his sturdy body is grea...

Clever, creative play is the name of the game with Olympia Octopus. Her unique shape and eight legs open doors to all kinds of solo and group acti...

Robbie is the most cheerful fluff your dog will ever meet! He's all dressed for playtime with his dapper scarf, and he's such a good snuggler, keep...