Under $25

Did you know that Archie loves playtime more than he loves bamboo? It’s true! He’s ready to hang out and snuggle up with his long, striped tail an...

Hip hop, the fun won’t stop when Oliver is around. This ribbitting rascal is ready to leap-frog into adventures with his new best friend. So, sha...

Ruby Rainbow Trout’s streamlined shape will lure your dog right in. Whether you play tug of war or fetch with her, she’ll land your dog hook, ...

This little guy knows all the scuttlebutt! Perfect for smaller dogs who love a companion with a lot of charisma, your pup will love catching up on ...

You’ll never meet a more devoted playmate than Betty. She’ll stick by your pup in the sun or the snow, and no one will come between them, no matter...

Don’t let his smaller size fool you - Burt is quite the catch for smaller dogs. His long, streamlined shape lures pups in for games of catch or ...

If your pup’s got a big holiday sweet tooth, our Extra Large Candy Cane will definitely hit the spot. Its traditional hook shape is perfect for all...

Our holiday candy cane is all of the sweet with none of the cavities. Your dog will appreciate the festive plush and a shape that’s perfect for tug...

With his bright red plush and frisky fins, Cedar Salmon is quite a catch. But beware, he’s a real player. No dog can resist his charming games of ...

Your dog will warm up to Esmeralda quickly. No hard exteriors here - Esmeralda’s shell is soft, plush and ready for snuggling. When she’s not a ...

Georgia Gator is the most popular gal in the swamp, thanks to a shape that any dog can enjoy. From shaking to squeaking to tug-of-war, Georgia’s t...

Our most popular of all the Fluff & Tuff toy family, and possibly the most popular plush toy in our store. Hendrix Fox is a high quality, durab...

Judy can’t wait to partner with your pup on the playroom floor this holiday season. It doesn’t matter if your pup has four left paws; Judy is ready...

Who needs a butterfly when a caterpillar is this adorable? Katie’s a spicebush swallowtail caterpillar who fools predators into thinking she’s a sn...

There’s nothing stinky about Lucy Skunk - in fact, she’s a beautiful little lady with an adorable pink nose and long fluffy tail. She’s soft enough...

Nuts Squirrel may hoard his acorns, but he’s always ready to share the fun. His fluffy tail is tempting for chasing, but his sturdy body is grea...

Peanut will burrow his way into your dog’s heart! He packs a lot of fun into a tiny package, and particularly loves rousing games of fetch, tug...

Rocket is a lovable rascal who’s always looking for play - and maybe a little bit of mischief. He’s sturdy enough for fetch and tug, but snuggly en...

Savannah is the cutest little gator in the swamp, and she’s ready to play! The smallest of our gator family, Savannah is shaped for tugging, shak...

There’s nothing hard about Shelly Turtle - she’s a sweetheart who is perfect for smaller dogs who love a good snuggle. Her floppy legs are separate...

Wally the Flying Mallard will make your dog’s imagination soar with his bright colors and detailed feathery wings. Dogs love to fetch, shake and tu...

Who doesn't want a Hippo for Christmas? Helga Hippo is hungry - for playtime and love all year long. Hippos are surprisingly fast creatures, so ...

Bring out the inner hunter in your pup with Ike the Flying Pheasant. He’s perfect for chasing or shaking by his floppy wings and tail feathers. Ik...

Put a little hop in playtime with Jessica the Bunny. She’s a great size for all types of dogs and a wide range of play styles, and super adorable ...